In short: Research on water left after washing rice measured friction and elasticity in existing hair fibres. A small human trial reported some positive results from a formulated rice-bran extract, a product materially different from rice-rinse water.

Evidence does not establish that rice-rinse water regrows thinning hair. A 2010 laboratory paper reported effects on the surface friction and elasticity of existing hair, while a 2015 human trial tested a formulated, standardised rice-bran supercritical carbon dioxide extract on people with diagnosed hair loss. The studies examined different materials and different outcomes, so the trial result cannot be transferred to homemade rice water (Inamasu and colleagues, 2010; Choi and colleagues, 2015).

The NHS lists illness, stress, cancer treatment, weight loss and iron deficiency among possible causes of temporary loss, while male and female pattern baldness tend to be permanent. It advises seeing a GP to get an idea of the cause before approaching a commercial hair clinic (NHS: Hair loss).

What evidence exists for rice water and hair growth?

The phrase "rice water" can cover materials that are far from interchangeable. In 2010, researchers studied rinse water obtained from washing rice, known as Yu-Su-Ru, and extracts made from that water. Five years later, a trial used a manufactured scalp tonic containing rice-bran supercritical carbon dioxide extract. Rice bran is the grain’s outer layer, while washing water contains material released when rice is rinsed (Inamasu and colleagues, 2010; Choi and colleagues, 2015).

A 2022 systematic-review abstract also focused on rice-bran extracts. Its authors searched PubMed in May 2021 and analysed ten studies, six concerning efficacy and four concerning safety. The abstract describes laboratory pathways and rice-bran research, but it does not establish that household rice-rinse water produces the same material or the same clinical result (Almohanna and colleagues, 2022).

What did the rice-rinse study measure?

The 2010 paper examined rice washing water as a hair treatment. Its abstract reports lower surface friction and greater elasticity after treatment. Those are properties of the existing hair fibre. They do not measure the number of active follicles, the rate of new growth or regrowth in a thinning area (Inamasu and colleagues, 2010).

The researchers also observed flaking on the hair surface when rinse water was used alone. They considered direct use difficult and went on to examine extracts designed to retain hair-care effects without that flaking. The paper therefore gives no clean basis for treating ordinary rinse water and a processed cosmetic extract as equivalent (Inamasu and colleagues, 2010).

Lower friction or greater elasticity may affect how a strand behaves during handling. A change in breakage, texture or retained length can alter appearance without showing that follicles have produced more hair (Inamasu and colleagues, 2010). Our guide to hair breakage versus hair loss explains why damage along the shaft and loss from the follicle require different evidence.

The publisher page provides an abstract with no full English methods account. Its reported work is on hair fibres, with no scalp trial in people who have thinning hair. Claims about clinical regrowth would go beyond the outcomes reported there (Inamasu and colleagues, 2010).

What did the 2015 human trial test?

The 2015 study was a 16-week, double-blind, randomised, placebo-controlled trial at one centre. Researchers enrolled 50 adults with diagnosed alopecia and assigned 25 to a rice-bran extract tonic and 25 to a tonic without the extract. Forty-three completed the visits and intervention; the efficacy analysis excluded seven people for poor compliance (Choi and colleagues, 2015).

The active product was a multi-component scalp tonic. Its rice ingredient had been produced from rice bran using supercritical carbon dioxide extraction. The formula also contained water, alcohol, glycerin, hyaluronic acid and other ingredients. A rinse made from washing rice does not reproduce that extraction process or formulation (Choi and colleagues, 2015).

Among male participants, changes in non-vellus hair count and dermatologist ratings of photographs favoured the extract over placebo after 16 weeks. Several female outcomes changed during the study, but the paper reports that results in women did not differ significantly from placebo overall. The findings came from small sex-specific groups and an analysis of completers at a single centre (Choi and colleagues, 2015).

The authors listed the single-centre design, small sample and missing blood-chemistry and hormonal assessments among the limitations. They called for larger, longer, multicentre studies. The study also had no follow-up after the 16-week intervention, so it did not show whether observed differences persisted (Choi and colleagues, 2015).

What remains uncertain?

No study in this source set tests household rice-rinse water as a treatment for follicular hair growth in people with thinning hair. That bounded finding comes from comparing the 2010 rinse-water paper, the 2015 rice-bran extract trial and the rice-bran focus of the 2022 review abstract (Inamasu and colleagues, 2010; Choi and colleagues, 2015; Almohanna and colleagues, 2022).

The human trial cannot answer whether a commercial product with "rice water" on its label matches the studied tonic. Ingredient source, extraction and the complete formula all affect whether it is the same intervention. A shampoo or rinse-off product also differs from the tonic assessed in the trial (Choi and colleagues, 2015).

The studies do not identify the cause of an individual’s thinning. NHS guidance says a GP may be able to identify the cause by looking at the hair and advises seeking help when hair loss is worrying. An ingredient claim cannot replace that assessment (NHS: Hair loss).

Risks and what can go wrong

The direct concern reported in the rinse-water paper was flaking on the hair surface. Researchers then investigated processed extracts. Their work did not establish ordinary rinse water as a suitable clinical treatment (Inamasu and colleagues, 2010).

No adverse reactions related to the active product were reported in the 2015 trial. That result covered one formulation, 43 completers and 16 weeks. The authors still identified missing clinical chemistry assessments and the need for larger, longer studies, so the trial cannot establish broad or long-term safety for other rice-derived products (Choi and colleagues, 2015).

A separate risk is delay in finding the reason for hair loss. NHS guidance notes that hair loss can sometimes be linked to a medical condition and advises seeing a GP before approaching a commercial hair clinic (NHS: Hair loss).

Questions to ask the clinic

  1. What diagnosis best explains the pattern of hair loss, and who made that assessment?
  2. Does the evidence concern rice washing water, rice bran or a processed rice extract?
  3. Was the exact product and complete formulation tested in people?
  4. Did the study measure strand friction, breakage, hair count, diameter or clinical photographs?
  5. How many people entered and completed the study, and how large were the comparison groups?
  6. Were results reported separately for men and women, and did they differ from placebo?
  7. How long did the study last, and was there follow-up after the product stopped?

Talk it through

If hair loss has been professionally assessed and surgery is being considered, GetHair can arrange a free consultation with a partner clinic. The clinic assesses the cause of hair loss, suitability and any proposed treatment; GetHair arranges the introduction.

Sources